“Does what it says on the tin, it could be improved if you could deliver the full 5A, at just 4.5 A that might exclude using it with some accessories.
A big plus is the full length NVMe slot.”
“Everything went well putting it together in a tall metal case I purchased from PiHut however a couple of things to note,
1/ I had to take it all apart again as the only SSD screw in stud is for the longest SSD the Raspberry Pi SSD's are all 2030 size so had to insert the included SSD fixing post for this then tested the system using preprogramed SSD OK but had to go throught the whole process again to insert the final SSD I wanted to use. The design flaw with this product is the fact that you cannot screw a fixing post into any of the other possitions from the top, without taking the whole thing apart. Annoying!
2/ The POE+ power supply as stated can only deliver 4.5amps not 5amps so warning sign all the time when using POE.
3/ Although the power is restricted the board produces a very high heat output far beyond the officail Raspberry Pi POE+ Hat so it all gets very hot even with all the pop outs on the sides of the case popped out so the case really needs a 2nd fan in the case top to take away the heat.
All that said and even with the Pi5 CPU at 50-60C I have it working at GEN 3 speeds doubling the performance and therefore meeting 900mbs for file transfers as it's a file server I feel the need for speed. I will just have to wait to see if there are any problems. Good product needs the SSD replacement problem fixing rev 2 as taking the whole thing apart to replace a memory chip is poor design.”
“Fiddly to put together and neither the included leaflet nor the online wiki go into the detail you really need to make sure you get the screws right. Also, the suggested case doesn't really have enough room for the fan: it can be bodged, but it's not very satisfactory: you might be better buying the standard Pi5 active cooler, which would probably fit ok under the hat (though I haven't tried this).
Also worth noting that you can do a straightforward network install (https://www.raspberrypi.com/documentation/computers/getting-started.html#installing-the-operating-system) straight on to the NVMe when you've got it all put together which avoids faffing about with a microSD card and all the shenanigans detailed in the wiki: it will be up and running in a couple of minutes.
As noted by another reviewer, you get a low-power warning even though it's drawing sufficient power from the PoE+ port, though that doesn't seem to be causing any problems.
I think this is adequate if you want both PoE and an NVMe and want to be able to get it in a case, but it could be more polished, particularly around the documentation. Ideally I'd prefer to use an NVMe base and a separate PoE hat, but I have yet to find a case that will house a Pi5 with an active cooler, a base and a hat.”
“Great addiition to a PI, make a perfect setup for a Raspberry based NAS server and MACOS Timemachine backup server. POE saves extra cable and power supply”