My first Cohorted box has left me somewhat underwhelmed! I waited in anticipation for my beautifully wrapped box of high end products and what I found was just a bit an anti-climax! While the NARS palette was nice, the beautiful design was lost with the first swatch and its now just a blurry mix of colours which doesn't really last too well on the eye. The ovali brush was good. The Smith & Cult nail varnish is in lovely packaging but the colour was not great nor has it staying power. Now I am torn, do I cancel my subscription now or give Cohorted the benefit of the doubt and wait another month?