Overall I would say they are amazing! For being a little thin for my liking they certainly kept out the cold. I received the knee grip edition, and they have amazing grip. My mare had a fresh moment and I stayed on, that’s got to count for something! I would personally love to see some thicker fabric to make me a little more comfortable (personal preference), however I do realise this can be solved by an additional under layer that can be purchased from AD’s website. Another thing I think will be an amazing addition would be belt loops around the waist. Although the waist band is as secure as I have found in leggings, it would be nice to have the additional option, whether it be for style or practicality. My final review is four stars. This is due to all the amazing additions such as the grip lined pockets to the thick waist, however that final star was not given for me as I still believe there could be a few things tweaked or added to make it the perfect pair of leggings!