I'm really sorry but I have to go by my dogs' reactions - neither of my dogs was impressed and one is a Labrador ! I bought quite a lot because I thought that whatever the reaction of my Cocker Spaniel, the Lab would eat it as she eats everything. However, she tried a mouthful and spat it out. The Cocker had a sniff and walked away. I have to admit the dogs' reactions were roughly how I reacted to the smell ! I was very surprised as both dogs are rescue; I have not had the Cocker for as long as I have had the Lab but neither has refused food before. I know that if I did not give them any other food they might eat it but I find that in these situations I give in before the dogs. I apologise again because I am sure it is very good. They won't eat the biscuits either so I am soaking those in warm water and putting out for the birds.