Will start with positive- Masks and small lipsticks are very good (though both lipsticks size is mini, which is disappointing, at least one of them could be proper size). in my box I didn’t get Nars eyeshadow as was stated in the booklet (was quite upset getting different brand eyeshadow instead); the contouring pallet is ok, but nothing special and contouring is not in fashion anymore - 2-3 years ago trend. Sample of cream and fragrance - anyone can get it for free in any big cosmetic stores, not impressed. It’s my first box with Cohortes - find it quite average, nothing speacial. Will give it another try, but if have same feeling about next one, will stop ordering.