Loved this box initially although my lip gloss had already been used - i could tell this as there was a pink smear on the applicator! And once again, the bronzer was too light for my skin. I do enjoy receiving the box but am finding myself giving away more than I use, and the value of the box is often wildly over inflated. It’s nice to be introduced to brands I haven’t tried yet but as I am dark skinned the makeup is inevitably aimed solely at a Caucasian complexion with no option to select anything else which is frustrating. On the whole, it could certainly do better!