I have been with Cohorted Beauty box since Nov 17. The Dec, Jan and February boxes were really good and I used all the products. The products felt high end and i would definitely buy them again. The April box was poor. The shampoo and conditioner felt cheap. There are low cost supermarket brands that are way better than this. The mascara cleaner i felt was a bit pointless. Make Up wipes or remover do the same job. The lip gloss was too similar to the one i got in December. The box was missing a Salt Spray and a Clarins sample. This box was definitely not as good as previous boxes. I hope it is just a one off, Lynn